Media release: Government needs to open New Zealand to investment, not close it

Media release
7 November, 2017

Wellington (7 November 2017): As Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, Foreign Minister Winston Peters and Trade Minister David Parker head for the APEC meeting and the East Asia Summit, The New Zealand Initiative welcomes the Government’s commitment to free trade agreements.

But the think tank warns that New Zealand will likely fall further behind as a destination for foreign investment (FDI) if the Government pursues its policy intentions.

Commenting on New Zealand’s trade and investment policy, the Initiative’s Executive Director Dr Oliver Hartwich said: “We have had a lot of political theatre on foreign investors in our housing market. And though New Zealand was, until now, relatively open to foreign investment in that area, in general we are now the most closed economy in the developed world as far as foreign direct investment is concerned.”

Dr Hartwich points out that in the OECD’s latest Foreign Direct Investment Restrictiveness Index, New Zealand came out last. No other advanced economy is as difficult to navigate for international investors as New Zealand. Only some developing economies are worse than New Zealand.

“Of all economies surveyed, only the Philippines, Saudi Arabia, Myanmar, China, Indonesia and Jordan are more restricted on FDI than New Zealand. And even Morocco, Cambodia and Vietnam have a more open FDI regime than New Zealand,” said Dr Hartwich.

“If we do not liberalise our FDI regime, New Zealanders will miss out on business opportunities. Every study shows that openness to FDI is important to create trade links, open new markets and get access to international value chains.”

“If the Prime Minister needs any inspiration on FDI, perhaps she could talk to her APEC hosts in Vietnam. Since the mid-1980s, the Vietnamese have reduced FDI barriers dramatically. They are now more open than New Zealand. At the same time, they have lifted inward investment from little more than zero percent of GDP to more than 50 percent of GDP,” said Dr Hartwich. “This is how you create growth, jobs and opportunity.”
 

Read more:
The New Zealand Initiative has previously documented the poor state of FDI regulations in a series of reports:
Open for Business: Removing the barriers to foreign investment, Dr Bryce Wilkinson 
Capital Doldrums: How globalisation is bypassing New Zealand, Dr Bryce Wilkinson
New Zealand's Global Links: Foreign Ownership and the Status of New Zealand's Net International InvestmentDr Bryce Wilkinson

ENDS

Dr Bryce Wilkinson and Dr Oliver Hartwich are available for interviews, please contact:


Linda Heerink, Communications Officer
The New Zealand Initiative
Phone: +64 4 494 9109
Mobile: +64 21 172 8036
Email: linda.heerink@nzinitiative.org.nz   

Appendix: The FDI Regulatory Restrictiveness Index (FDI Index) measures statutory restrictions on foreign direct investment. A value of ‘0’ represents an open economy; a value of ‘1’ is a closed economy. Negative changes between 1997 and 2016 are an improvement (and vice versa). Source: http://www.oecd.org/investment/fdiindex.htm  
 

Country

OECD FDI Index 2016

OECD FDI Index 1997

Change
(1997-2016)

New Zealand

0.240

0.240

0.000

Mexico

0.193

0.287

-0.094

Iceland

0.167

0.167

0.000

Canada

0.166

0.267

-0.101

Australia

0.146

0.266

-0.120

Korea

0.135

0.532

-0.397

Israel

0.118

0.113

0.005

Austria

0.106

0.158

-0.052

United States

0.089

0.089

0.000

Norway

0.085

0.094

-0.009

Switzerland

0.083

0.154

-0.071

Poland

0.072

0.165

-0.093

OECD - Average

0.067

0.127

-0.060

Sweden

0.059

0.079

-0.020

Turkey

0.059

0.283

-0.224

Chile

0.057

0.073

-0.016

Italy

0.052

0.058

-0.006

Japan

0.052

0.079

-0.027

Slovak Republic

0.049

0.067

-0.018

France

0.045

0.055

-0.010

Ireland

0.043

0.050

-0.007

Belgium

0.040

0.148

-0.108

United Kingdom

0.040

0.081

-0.041

Denmark

0.033

0.038

-0.005

Greece

0.032

0.071

-0.039

Hungary

0.029

0.154

-0.125

Latvia

0.026

 

0.026

Germany

0.023

0.030

-0.007

Spain

0.021

0.036

-0.015

Finland

0.019

0.178

-0.159

Estonia

0.018

0.076

-0.058

Netherlands

0.015

0.020

-0.005

Czech Republic

0.010

0.046

-0.036

Portugal

0.007

0.043

-0.036

Slovenia

0.007

0.100

-0.093

Luxembourg

0.004

0.004

0.000


Non-OECD economies

Country

OECD FDI Index 2016

OECD FDI Index 1997

Change (1997-2016)

Philippines

0.398

 

 

Saudi Arabia

0.364

 

 

Myanmar

0.356

 

 

China (People's
Republic of)

0.327

 

 

Indonesia

0.315

 

 

Jordan

0.243

 

 

India

0.212

 

 

Malaysia

0.211

 

 

Tunisia

0.206

 

 

Lao People's
Democratic Republic

0.187

 

 

Russia

0.187

 

 

Ukraine

0.124

 

 

Viet Nam

0.115

 

 

Kazakhstan

0.112

 

 

Brazil

0.101

 

 

Mongolia

0.098

 

 

Kyrgyzstan

0.079

 

 

Peru

0.077

 

 

Morocco

0.067

 

 

Egypt

0.062

 

 

South Africa

0.055

 

 

Cambodia

0.052

 

 

Costa Rica

0.048

 

 

Lithuania

0.034

 

 

Argentina

0.031

 

 

Colombia

0.026

 

 

Romania

0.008

 

 

Stay in the loop: Subscribe to updates